Wednesday, June 5, 2013
Thinking about Empathy
I have a number of questions/opinions/observations/experiences that are buzzing around my head. It would help to write them and talk them through with anyone who is brave enough. :-)
The fundamental question is how do we use empathy to help people given the great numbers of difficulties involved?
Some of my experiences come to mind. Over the past year I have watched some of my very dearest friends suffer unbearable tragedies - honestly, the horror of the situations astounds me. I am thinking of at least five different families struck unexpectedly each with more than one horror and each situation I and most people would not have experienced or even encountered, and each of these situations are ongoing. By the end of the January school holidays I wanted to crawl into a small cupboard with my knitting and maybe a book, and not come out for a very long time. I was emotionally exhausted. (Perhaps my own experience during the same year as mother of a suddenly critically ill son added to my sadness and tiredness.) People told me that if I was going to look care meaningfully for people in such crisis situations, I needed to look after myself but I am not sure if that is enough. I don't know the answer to this. At the end of January, I had just had a holiday, albeit one tinged with many sadnesses.
So, what is empathy? No-one can fully know the pain in my friends lives, so they can't fully empathize, and neither would anyone ask them too. I know that I don't want anyone I talk to to experience the fear and sadness i felt last year when Chris was in hospital. It won't help me in my resolution of my feelings to pass that suffering onto someone else. Sure, I like the idea of being listened to, but not to cause anyone else to experience my pain. That would just add to my pain, I think.
But hang on, the bible teaches us to bear each other's burdens, to put other's needs before our own, to "weep with those who weep". Does that mean I should take on as much of the other's suffering as I possibly can? Will that actually help them? Should I also let others do that for me? And what does that mean? If I want to empathize with a man whose wife has suddenly died leaving him and his children grief stricken, should I take on that same level of grief and devastation? How would that work? Would that even help? And what would it take for me to enter into that experience with him? How would the other people in my life cope with me if I were doing that? And isn't the need for empathy rather self-centred, possibly to the point of not helping? (I don't say that lightly either-see below)
I don't have any real answers for these problems. I have tried a number of things and I think they have been valuable but far from sufficient to ease the suffering in my friends lives. Maybe I need to feel like I am doing something as a way of dealing with the sadness i feel when I consider their situations, and the fear that something worse could happen to them. I listen to them, and I seek to help with some of the practical needs in their lives where I can. But I am not sure that I want to empathize, and I am not sure that I ever really can.
I heard a talk by a lady recently who had suffered a series of heartbreaking losses and whose life was forever changed as a result. "Getting over it" was not an option and life would never be the same for her. But what worked for her in helping the grip of grief to ease was looking outside herself, involving herself in helping other suffering people, caring for them, thinking about them, lifting her eyes away from her own situation for a while. This made an enormous difference to this lady, and I think it is not really a foreign idea for Christians at least. When God tells us to "Weep with those who weep" its as much for us as it is for them. I am sure this is why people whose relatives have been victims of crime start support organisations to care for, advise and advocate for others in their situation. Its cathartic but also gives them something else to think about, gets them out of their own fog and helps them to think about others experiences. This is one of my problems with the idea of empathy when it is directed at me. It will reinforce my Robyn-centredness, and I am not sure that that is all that helpful.
When I said I liked the idea of being listened to, I am not sure that I like the idea of being deeply empathized with. I would love to talk through how it felt when Chris was ill, but I don't want to do that with a friend. It was greatly imbalance the friendship, making my friend more like a counsellor. I want to have a happy two-way relationship with all my friends. They know I have had a tough year, and that is enough. If I wanted to talk about my experiences in detail, I would do it with "someone who doesn't love me" (as my GP wisely said). I probably will do that at some time.
I have another friend who rarely sees the happy side of life. I talk to her often and empathize with her situation, but to be honest, many of the things she complains about are trivial. She has become accustomed to complaining, and I know she enjoys pouring out her troubles (on me) and it makes her feel better. But I don't think this is getting her anywhere. There are things that she needs to change, and different ways to look at her life. Listening to herself talk about how tough things are, and how much everyone she knows lets her down, just reminds her of the negative (?) things, and having me empathize with her, (I think) is doing the same. I realise that she doesn't have the confidence to make the changes that seem necessary but I am not seeing that having someone to talk to is making enough difference. (Perhaps the answer is to get involved in the lives of others and start caring about them.)
Well, this blog got a long way away from the fundamental question and became very Robyn-focussed, but I meant only to use myself and my life as an example, not to look for any understanding. I would like to have some thoughts from readers of this blog about the questions that I ask.
There were a few other things I wanted to say, but I can't remember them. I might add them later. Please comment and let there be discussion.
Sunday, May 12, 2013
Getting our Kids to Live Generously
I would like to start a conversation between wise and experienced Christian parents for whom generosity has been a part of their lives probably since before they were parents. What is it about our children's generation that makes them so different.
But if life habits are usually formed before the age of around 22, what hope is there for missions, churches, charities, refugees, the poor in the third world?
This is what I see in the bible:
- In Luke CH 16 Jesus says to use your money for the kingdom of God. If we in the first world want more people in the kingdom, then its going to cost us money. Whats wrong with that? Don't we worship God more than we worship our money? What about our children? Who do they really worship?
- Proverbs 11:24 "A generous man will prosper; he who refreshes others will himself be refreshed" (warning- not a verse about how to get more money)
- Proverbs 19:17 "Whoever is kind to the poor lends to the LORD, and he will reward them for what they have done."
- etc etc etc
Monday, April 15, 2013
What my husband isn't telling me
However, last week, even as I was considering this new phase of married life, I heard an interview with David Murrow about his new book "What your husband isn't telling you.". The interviewer, Leigh Hatcher, seemed to really like it. I thought to myself, I better read this. It possibly was a direct sign from God I had prayed about this only moments before. In that case, reading it is definitely required.
The blurb on the back says :
Your husband learned from an early age to deny his true feeling - and to be silent about his deepest needs. Most men long for greater intimacy with their wives, but they have no idea how to find it.
Bestselling author David Murrow breaks the silence, uncovering the central secret of your spouse's heart. he reveals what every husband since Adam has felt by has been unwilling or unable to say.
If you really want to know what's stored up in your husband's heart, read this book. You'll not only understand him better, you'll love and respect him more.
"Well" I think to myself, "I would like to do that". So I bought a copy of the book and am just starting to read it. I will report back.
I did look at some online reviews, and noticed that the book wasn't universally applauded. Alot of men thought it was wonderful and alot of women didn't. I am not sure what to make of that, and I expect I might disagree with some of it, and perhaps ever find some of it distasteful, but I will persevere in the hope of learning more about what is in the heart of my husband that he hasn't told me about.
Sunday, April 14, 2013
Generosity - why is it good?
Anyway, today's bible reading included many helpful verses about generosity from Proverbs Ch 11. These verses resonate with me and my experience.
- V 25 reminds of the joy of giving - "A generous man will prosper, he who refreshes others will himself be refreshed" and
- V26 "People curse the may who hoards grain but blessing crowns him who is willing to sell".
- V28 "Whoever trusts in his riches will fall but the righteous will thrive like a green leaf".
But generosity is rewarded. How? With refreshment and joy, with the respect of others. 2 Corinthians ever says that God loves a cheerful giver. So the point is that generosity needs to be an attitude of the heart. We don't do it for a reward, but we get rewarded anyway, in all kinds of ways, including the joy of a connection with people we don't otherwise know, and the satisfaction of seeing God use our small contributions to great ends in his kingdom.
But I don't think generosity is just about money. Its easier sometimes to make an online deposit than give of our time and energy. I think God loves both kinds of cheerful givers and rewards them both, but the reward in terms of satisfaction is even greater when time and emotional connections are involved. Riskier too, but the greater the risk, the greater to joy.
Thursday, April 11, 2013
Understanding Teenagers- (pretending we do, at least)
Young kids rarely question the behaviour of the adults around them. They accept it, but teenagers start to look for authenticity in their parents. They are much more interested in what you do that what you say, so your example much more important than your words. Sorry, that sounds rather preachy, but I am just repeating what I heard, and what resonates with me. My kids are 17, 18 and 19 and they will spot hypocrisy in my in a second. If we want our teens to treat us with respect, to start with, we need to live the way we claim to value. Walk the walk, not just talk the talk. It sounds really obvious, but when you are in a crisis of conflict with your offspring, its easy to act and speak out of anger and self-protection rather than kindness. (see previous blog post)
The first thing Colleen emphasized was important Family strengths. Work on cohesiveness, flexibility and communication.
- Cohesiveness: emphasize you family connection and provide a healthy (emotional) environment
- Flexibility: whatever happens, be there for your teens, but recognise that people's timetables are different. Don't be too rigid. Embrace the differences between you and them. Make time to spent with your teens.
- Communication: the most important thing. Be ready to listen, and they might even listen to us from time to time. Always love them.
Respect
Proverbs 11:12 "A man who lacks judgement derides his neighbour but a man of understanding holds his tongue"
Commentary: (See also verse 9) Gossip and derision will harm others but do not benefit the gossiper. This proverb is one of many dealing with the advantages of knowing when to keep silent.
Me: So relevant to parenting. Don't fight with your teens. A woman of understanding knows when to stay silent. (eg when they are angry or when you are angry)
Proverbs 11:16-17 "A kindhearted woman gains respect but ruthless men gain only wealth. A kind man benefits himself but a cruel man brings trouble on himself"
Commentary "In their lust for possessions fools scorn that which is of far greater value: relationships built on respect. There is legitimate self-interest expressed in the command to love your neighbour as yourself. What is best for others is best for us"
Me: Its not hard to see how these three verses complement each other. Poor use of the tongue is cruel and doesn't benefit us or the hearer. Don't fight with your teens. (Can you see a theme happening here?) If they seem disrespectful, getting angry and telling them off is not going to make that any better. Be respectable - calm down, demonstrate kindheartedness and self control. It will go better for you and for them.
More about teens later. This is quickly written. Love to have a conversation, though. Please add your thoughts.
Wednesday, April 10, 2013
An odd memory from high school
This comes back to me every time I go to my collection of vitamins or other supplements. On the kitchen bench so I remember to take them daily is Glucosamine to keep the arthritic changes in my hand from getting worse, Caltrate to ward off osteoarthritis, which runs in my family, krill oil (super strength) to bring down my cholesterol and a multivitamin (for the over 50s) for everything else. One time I took all of them at once on an empty stomach. I won't be doing that again.
So "whats wrong with taking health supplements?" I ask the memory of my school friend? These ones at least do seem to have some scientific credibility.
Her reply would be (now she is even older than me and no doubt decorating her kitchen bench in a similar way) that the point she was making wasn't anti-vitamin but pro-Jesus. Her parents were putting their hope in their health and that's a dangerous thing to do because it doesn't matter how powerful your fish-oil is, everybody dies. We can and should look after our earthly bodies as well as we can but always with our eyes on the one who will soon be giving us a body that will never let us down again.
"Do not collect for yourselves treasures on earth, where moth and rust destroy, and where thieves break in and steal. But collect for yourselves treasures in heaven, where neither moth nor rust destroys and where thieves do not break in and steal. Matthew 6:19-20
Tuesday, April 9, 2013
TO DO:
Write Blog
There is only one thing on my to do list. I used to write long to do lists, and sometimes I got alot of the items done. But usually, as I diligently added tasks to the long list that extended onto a second page, I ended up becoming totally discouraged by the length of the unachieveable list, and giving up and finding something nicer to do.
But I have found the answer to this. I now have a one-item to-do list. When I have completed the item, I can tick it off and smugly have a coffee and feel like a total success. Then I can write another to do list, and complete that task and double my satisfaction. Wow, two to-do lists completed today, well done Robyn. You are a legend.
So : Write Blog. Tick.
:)
Feel smug. Tick.
Sunday, April 7, 2013
Hmmm! (warning- a bit gross)
I did sit down at the table at my laptop on a number of occasions and was bothered by a strange odour. I looked at the various things on the table, including a roll of fishing line, and decided that they did indeed smell, so I put them away but each time the smell remained. I bleached and mopped the laundry floor thinking that the cats might be responsible for the smell (which was bothering me more and more and starting to remind me of an open sewer). By the end of the weekend I was even going to the length of wiping my laptop down with disinfectant. Oddly, my family never mentioned the smell although to be fair I was so busy with other commitments I hardly saw them.
I am so glad that our bin goes out Sunday night and in it, the reason for the totally rank smell - which Mal never smelt but the 'culprit', thank goodness, Malcolm discovered when we got home from our church dinner at about 9pm. On a chair pushed under the table was a bag of meat, about 4 kg, (2 kg extra lean mince and some previously yummy-looking, now offensive, mango chicken fillets) bought from the butcher on Friday. I was busy cooking and preparing for the weekend events and managed to put only three of the four bags away.
I am so glad I did not wakeup to that stench this morning. The garbos can have it.
Feeling foolish now.
I was really looking forward to that chicken too. :-/
Seventeen years ago a house church which we had been attending for 12 years closed. We all decided it was time to do something new and better. But it was like shutting your family so we agreed to still see each other regularly. And we have. Last night we met for our annual dinner. What a wonderful night that was. I never thought we would stick to the commitment to stay together. But one of our wonderful faithful ex-members has organised all the subsequent get-togethers and assured the continuation of the family and we are all so grateful for her efforts.
So we had a delightful time around the fire at the Blue Mountains home of Mark and Lyndal. What a joy to still have such great evenings with such precious brothers and sisters after all these years.
Saturday, April 6, 2013
Yesterday
A few years ago the teens in my family were causing me some real heartache daily. However, a song we sang in church, (which I am again practicing today) is called "I have a shelter in the storm." I am not kidding or being flippant here. The image of Jesus keeping his children safe through storms was and is still a powerful one and very relevant to all of us, including those whose stormy teen parenting experience is beyond what they think they can handle.
Why Spend your Labour on what does not Satisfy?
I am going to put it all in this blog post for your encouragement too. If you don't like reading long bible passage just read the underlined bits, but please do read. And have your thirst quenched.
come to the waters;
and you who have no money,
come, buy and eat!
Come, buy wine and milk
without money and without cost.
2 Why spend money on what is not bread,
and your labor on what does not satisfy?
Listen, listen to me, and eat what is good,
and you will delight in the richest of fare.
3 Give ear and come to me;
listen, that you may live.
I will make an everlasting covenant with you,
my faithful love promised to David.
4 See, I have made him a witness to the peoples,
a ruler and commander of the peoples.
5 Surely you will summon nations you know not,
and nations you do not know will come running to you,
because of the Lord your God,
the Holy One of Israel,
for he has endowed you with splendor.”
call on him while he is near.
7 Let the wicked forsake their ways
and the unrighteous their thoughts.
Let them turn to the Lord, and he will have mercy on them,
and to our God, for he will freely pardon.
neither are your ways my ways,”
declares the Lord.
9 “As the heavens are higher than the earth,
so are my ways higher than your ways
and my thoughts than your thoughts.
10 As the rain and the snow
come down from heaven,
and do not return to it
without watering the earth
and making it bud and flourish,
so that it yields seed for the sower and bread for the eater,
11 so is my word that goes out from my mouth:
It will not return to me empty,
but will accomplish what I desire
and achieve the purpose for which I sent it.
12 You will go out in joy
and be led forth in peace;
the mountains and hills
will burst into song before you,
and all the trees of the field
will clap their hands.
13 Instead of the thornbush will grow the juniper,
and instead of briers the myrtle will grow.
This will be for the Lord’s renown,
for an everlasting sign,
that will endure forever.”
Thursday, April 4, 2013
Thinking about prayer
Since that conversation, the torment has actually eased significantly. Also the situation that was tormenting me has also eased.
No doubt the easing of my struggle was, to a significant extent, due to the act of sharing my trouble with an empathetic friend, and knowing that she enlisting supernatural help on my behalf. This effort on her part is not a small thing, and contributes to my sense of being listened to and actively cared for, which change how I respond to the issue.
Reading passages such at Ephesians Ch 1 where Paul is recording his prayer for the Ephesian church, or Colossians Ch 1 as another example, Paul didn't have to tell these people that he was praying for them to ensure the power of God would impact them in awesome ways. But, and God has designed it this way, part of the way God will answer this prayer is through Paul's words to them.
a) This beloved apostle has been impacted by their love for him to the extent that he will pray for them. That would be hugely encouraging.
b) The details of his prayer which record his empathy for them, his joy in their faith and his desires for them in the future would spur them on to greater Godliness, and greater courage under persecution.
c) He is also teaching them how to pray for others who they wish to see grow spiritually (and by the grace of God, he is also teaching us)
At the start of all Paul's letters, he wishes the reader/hearer grace and peace. He then goes on to pass on grace and peace to them from God through his words.
Its so important that we in the church talk to each other about prayer. "How can I pray for you?" seems much more essential than "how did your soccer team go?" (although there is a place for such a discussion with people less familiar to us).
God answered my friends prayer for me before she even prayed it, in part, by giving me someone to share with. Then she put it before Him and he continued to work in a situation which he was already working in.
A few years ago I read Philip Yancey's book Prayer. I was greatly impacted by his thoughts on the topic and I would recommend it to anyone. Its clear that prayer is about our expression of our dependence on God as the sovereign Lord. Its true that, amazingly, God listens to us and works in accordance with our requests, but the most important thing is that we pray, not what the answers look like. Prayer is always good for us.
Wednesday, April 3, 2013
School Scripture Lessons
- seeing the truths of God make sense to the students and fill them with excitement about knowing him
- learning these truths more fully myself as I get to know how God has revealed himself to mankind
- learning to explain profound stuff in a simple way that resonates with the students
- being reminded constantly what God has done for us
- getting to be part of a lovely team of people
- being prayed for by school parents and teachers
- getting the privilege of telling people about Jesus
- seeing the students grow in their understanding of God over time
- finding out years later that kids have given their lives to God.
- putting what I learn in scripture into practice in other areas of my life including parenting, church and personal relationships
- joy - lots of it
- seeing God work through my weakness. One of the most helpful things I ever learnt about scripture teaching was that I wasn't very good at it.
Tuesday, April 2, 2013
The Getting of Wisdom
Surely its only a powerful work of God's spirit that reveals this truth to us. The wisdom of the world is in opposition to God's wise truth. But Christians get it because God shows it to us, so that this "foolishness" becomes the best wisdom we have ever heard - something to build our lives on which makes perfect sense.
Monday, April 1, 2013
Verse of the day and a new goal
Proverbs 8:10-11
For someone like me who lacks self-discipline, setting goals is really helpful. I could set a hundred goals but I think its wise to start with one. This year, I have noticed that my prayer life has slipped away. People who pray see God working in their lives much more clearly. So:
Goal: Pray for 15 minutes a day. Using a prayer list, I will stay on track with this (that's the plan, anyway)
Note: This doesn't have much to do with my verse of the day, but praying is wise, so that's a link, isn't it?
My mentor
In a sense, I am killing 2 birds with the one stone (awful metaphor) as I need a ministry mentor for my studies, and need a personal mentor because I don't know many older Christians and should be learning from someone older than me. I have read a number of publications on mentoring recently and am convinced that its a biblical model for personal spiritual growth.
After only one session, I feel much more motivated and encouraged. I am excited to get to know this smart, experienced, enthusiastic woman who is spending her retirement ministering to others. I hope that I also will be able to pass on some wisdom and knowledge to younger Christians in time.
Saturday, March 30, 2013
Easter Sunday
and because he has, we have a responsibility to worship him with our whole lives
and we do that by caring for the people around us the way he would do
but its very hard. I think the hardest thing is knowing what to say to people. I have been thinking about this on two levels.
Firstly, what to say when people are grieving. Most people say they don't know what to say. Well of course they don't because there are no magic words that will make a tragic situation better or stop the pain. But it seems that many many people just back away from the hurt person for fear of saying the wrong thing. Talk to a hurt person. They don't want advice or insight. They want you to listen to them, to cry with them, to be with them, to grieve with them. You don't have to say anything. It can be awkward and it can be scary, but its so much better than leaving your friend to grieve on their own.
Secondly, what to say if you think you can see that your friend can do something about their problem, but you are scared or alienating or hurting them.
That, I don't know. Jesus spoke some hard truths to people sometimes, but I am not him. I don't have his authority and I don't have his warmth or wisdom. I am not prepared to take the risk that she will feel judged. So I will do other things to care for her, but not do what could be the best thing.
So, that's not really much to do with the resurrection of Jesus, or everything to do with it.
Friday, March 29, 2013
Integration.
Starting out
The purpose of this blog is firstly to do what is required by my spiritual formation course. I am supposed to write a daily learning journal. This has never come naturally to me, coughs semester I have basically forgotten to do it.
I also really feel the need to write my thoughts at times and I also think I have been through enough hard things in my life to have some useful insights. But that sentiment assumes that people might read it, but I am not sure what I think about that.